geek
New Member
Posts: 5
|
Post by geek on Jan 15, 2016 13:03:25 GMT
After multiple deletions of my comments Brother Adam Deen has al-Hamdulillah decided to not censor them any longer.
I feel my copy, paste and submit ad infinitum approach has worked.
A real victory for aql, human rights and free speech.
It seems as Mufti sahib has indicated that he does not want to engage in a substantiation of his initial position - 'his burden of proof'.
But I really hope he now provides references for his position from both primary and secondary literature from within the Maturidi theological school inshaAllah.
|
|
|
Post by muslimanswers on Jan 15, 2016 14:35:33 GMT
^
Salam Alaykum,
With regards to showing exampled of 'Hanafi Maturidi' instances where this was applied to apostasy in particular, my advice is: Don't hold your breath. The Shaykh of the "Avicenna Academy" who holds a similar position, said at the end of his video that the 'real Hanafi methodology' would lead to there being no punishment of any kind on the apostate, yet he also said that Hanafi scholars have not applied this due to not being able to use the methodology properly, and he implied that for him even though Abu Hanifa's (RA) position may have been one thing, he (RA) said that no one should follow his (RA) opinions unless that person knows where they came from .
|
|
Abu Idris
Junior Member
http://www.al-rahma.co.uk/
Posts: 79
|
Post by Abu Idris on Feb 2, 2016 13:38:07 GMT
|
|
Abu Idris
Junior Member
http://www.al-rahma.co.uk/
Posts: 79
|
Post by Abu Idris on Feb 8, 2016 12:50:08 GMT
Just like Geek, my comment on the recent page of Adam Deen’s blog did not get uploaded - despite other later messages being uploaded. He has updated his post as can be viewed on the following link: adamdeen.com/2016/02/06/my-thoughts-on-the-big-questions-do-we-need-a-british-islsam/
Unfortunately, I did not save my comment prior to posting. The crux of my question was: if you have problems with certain aspects of a divine law and wish to ‘modify’ it to a King James’ version of Islam, are you wanting to follow a man-made religion and not one sent down from the Divine?
|
|