|
Post by IbnNurAlShanti on Feb 6, 2016 23:48:42 GMT
The "REAL" Fadha'il al-A'malby Shaykh Mohammad Yasir al-Hanafi
We've heard attacks time and time again regarding the authenticity of narrations in Shaykh Zakariyya's Fadha'il al-A'mal. It's obvious that the ahlul batil, especially the salafis, were not comfortable with the fact that this book guided so many people and so they decided to make their own "authentic" Fadha'il al-A'mal. Find out in this video, just how authentic this book really is, it's surprising!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 14, 2016 5:38:14 GMT
Why do Deobandi Brothers think that their Fadhaail A'maal is so important that any other book written on the topic of Fadhaail is a direct refutation to that!? This book on the other hand was originally written by an Arab Shaykh by the name, "الصحيح المسند من فضائل الأعمال" and is translated from that. So it has no concerns with what an Indian Shaykh might have written by this name.
Secondly, has Yasir even bothered to read the Muqaddimah of the author or is he simply shooting arrows in the air. This tells us how sincere he really is.
Thirdly, even if it contains some slightly weak narrations, it is still nothing compared to the fabrications found in Fadhaa'il A'maal. Has he ever bothered to explain those!?
It seems as if even Yasir knows how the du'f of these narrations found in the book really is, that is why he is confining himself to only mentioning the page numbers instead of actually mentioning the hadeeth.
You are free to compare this book with Fadhaail A'maal, if the result comes anywhere near, then we can talk!
Remember, One should not stone the houses of others, when one's own house is made of glass.
|
|